Share with your friends


Analytics Magazine

Last Word: A Hiring Incident in the Desert

March/April 2010


Gene WoolseyBy Gene Woolsey

Some years ago there was a nameless National Laboratory somewhere in this great land of ours. The laboratory’s main reason for existence was to improve the design of various kinds of thermonuclear devices, build them and store them. But like all government laboratories, its reason for existence slid glacially and asymptotically toward “pure” research. The way to get promoted or raised was to publish more papers in the “respectable” journals in the field. The most far-out department was the mathematics group. In theory their job was to provide whatever applied mathematics and optimization that any other part of the plant might need. The truth, however, was that its members happily had been doing, were doing and proposed to continue to do, “pure” research in whatever area of pure mathematics ran their motor.

Now the mathematics department was an aggressive recruiter and scouted out mainly those university math departments that satisfied its requirement of outstanding ability in pure mathematics. The result was, with a few exceptions, the mathematics department was made up of rather weird haystack-haired people who adored pure mathematics, chess and Kriegspiel. Kriegspiel took place every day at noon and is, in essence, playing chess where you and your opponent have a board and pieces but cannot see each other’s board. Only the close to reality. But I digress.

Many people who worked at this laboratory were blissfully unaware that it was operated by a phone company under contract with the Atomic Energy Commission. What that meant in practice was as follows: If you applied for a mathematics position in parts of the phone company and that organization didn’t find you desirable, they would automatically forward your application, as a courtesy, to the math department at the National Laboratory where it would land on the math department head’s desk. In time a very bright, young Ph.D. from a prestigious nameless western school we shall call Berkeford, applied to a mathematics division of the phone company. He was brought out but, alas, didn’t make the cut. A week or so later he received a letter offering him an interview in the math department at the National Laboratory.

This young man was a Class A “Ban the Bomber” San Francisco pot-using hippie and wrote a letter to the department head stating how outraged he was to be contacted by a “bomb factory.” The letter continued in an explosive way that he would see us all in Hades before even considering working for such an evil organization that designed thermonuclear devices with which to kill people. He also sent a copy of this letter to the vice president of human resources at the phone company, demanding that the process of forwarding bulletin board and challenged any member of his department to write a reply; the author of the best response would receive a bottle of Château Lafitte-Rothschild. It wasn’t long before some really witty letters were put up, including one that everyone agreed was the winner. For political reasons, it couldn’t be sent as it was not classified, but it was too truthful. The letter follows:

Dear Dr. Hippie,

As I am sure you know, your letter telling us all to go to hell provoked some interesting reactions here. There was a contest for the best reply, which follows.

Firstly, you must realize that at one time this facility was really pretty much a bomb factory, no question. However, as the years passed, its connection to anything real and anything having to do with the design, improvement and storage of thermonuclear devices has become a minuscule part of our expenditure. Our math department is really an ivory tower full of Ph.D.s. Our job is to push back the frontiers of pure mathematics while being paid a salary to research on what we damned please while being compensated with salaries that can only be described as “amazing, munificent or wonderful.”

You stated in your letter that you didn’t want to join us because this would make you a contributor to the proliferation of thermonuclear devices. And by accepting a salary you said that you would be part of the people aiding and abetting government expenditure on thermonuclear war.

Nothing could be further from the truth!

In my many years in the mathematics division I can honestly say that not one study done by this department has ever been of any use to anyone on the real side of the house. We have been outrageously paid to do what we pleased. And we pleased to do pure mathematics.

To get straight to the point, if you join us, not only are you NOT accepting tainted money, you are diverting government money that was going to bomb design and improvement to support your salary so you may continue to campaign for peace. And remember, every dollar you absorb is a dollar that didn’t go into the design and improvement of thermonuclear devices. If you join us and work very hard you can divert more money from atomic weapon studies than any other way.

So you see, the best way you can siphon away bomb-directed money and support peace is to join us!

Yours for peace,
(Name withheld)

Gene Woolsey ( is professor emeritus at the Colorado School of Mines, a past president of The Institute of Management Sciences (TIMS) and a former editor of several journals including The Production & Inventory Management Journal, Interfaces, The Journal of Operations Management and The Transactions of The Institute of Industrial Engineers.



Study: The magic of animated movies not tied to latest technology

In the nearly 60 years between the 1939 release of Hollywood’s first full-length animated movie, “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs” and modern hits like “Toy Story,” “Shrek” and more, advances in animation technology have revolutionized not only animation techniques, but moviemaking as a whole. However, a new study in the INFORMS journal Organization Science found that employing the latest technology doesn’t always ensure creative success for a film. Read more →

Six finalists named for Edelman Award

INFORMS selected a diverse group of six finalists for the 47th annual Franz Edelman Award for Achievements in Operations Research and Management Science, the world’s most prestigious award for achievement in the practice of analytics and O.R. The 2018 finalists, who will present their work before a panel of judges at the INFORMS Conference on Analytics & Operations Research in Baltimore on April 15-17, included innovative applications in broadcasting, healthcare, communication, inventory management, vehicle fleet management and alternative energy. Read more →

Are Super Bowl ads worth it? New research suggests benefits persist

On Feb. 4, more than 40 percent of U.S. households will watch the 2018 Super Bowl game on TV. Advertisers will pay up to $4 million for a 30-second spot during the telecast. Is the high cost of advertising worth it? A new study finds that the benefits from Super Bowl ads persist well into the year with increased sales during other sporting events. Further, the research finds that the gains in sales are much more substantial when the advertiser is the sole advertiser from its market category or niche in a particular event. Read more →



2018 INFORMS Conference on Business Analytics and Operations Research
April 15-17, 2018, Baltimore


CAP® Exam computer-based testing sites are available in 700 locations worldwide. Take the exam close to home and on your schedule:

For more information, go to